Back to selection
Big Art/Little Debt/Together
I first met producer, director and non-profit executive Esther Robinson in the early aughts, when she was Film/Video Program Director at Creative Capital, a still invaluable organization that not only funds bold work but helps artists in their paths towards overall sustainability. Later, in 2006, I selected her for our 25 New Faces while she was in production on her luminous documentary A Walk Into the Sea, about her uncle, Danny Lyons, a filmmaker at Warhol’s Factory. In the years since, Robinson has been a contributor here, conducting the occasional interview but most notably writing columns that spoke uncomfortable but necessary truths about the economic life of artists in late-stage capitalism. If in our earliest issues we valorized filmmakers recklessly putting their production budgets on their credit cards, Robinson in a 2009 series on filmmakers and their second jobs preached the necessity of a good side hustle, convincing filmmakers such as Barry Jenkins, Tze Chun, Joe Swanberg and Liza Johnson to reveal the wage labor they undertook before their entertainment industry careers took off. In 2010, after the financial crisis, she issued a manifesto of sorts, the “Big Art/Little Debt” plan. “If you don’t crave risk on some level, then you’re likely not a filmmaker,” she wrote. “We can’t let go of risk. Without it our movies won’t get made, and if they do, they won’t have what makes our best movies sing. But we must also make sure that the thrill of the impossible doesn’t also sink us financially. And frankly, there’s no way for us purely independent filmmakers to know what to financially count on from our movies right now.” She went on to propose three commandments: “Make work that matters; get right with thy personal cash; and know and keep to thy limits.”
In the 15 years since Robinson wrote “Big Art/Little Debt,” its message has become even more relevant and echoes much of what is recommended by the younger non-Dē filmmakers. Below, Robinson looks back on the piece and brings it forward to the present day. — Scott Macaulay
When I first wrote Big Art/Little Debt, it was a practical guide for filmmakers trying to stay solvent while making uncompromising work. But today the ideas have taken on a new urgency. It isn’t just about budgeting — it’s about locating our power in a moment when everything around us is being strip-mined for profit.
The collapse of distribution isn’t a tragedy of technology; it’s the logical outcome of consolidation. A handful of companies now control the cultural pipes, extracting value from artistic labor with unprecedented efficiency. And this extraction is not limited to artists. (It never was, right?) Everyone’s creative energy is being mined — teachers, nurses, coders, carpenters. Regular everyday life is becoming unaffordable in the same way independent filmmaking has been unaffordable for decades.
Because here is what is starkly more clear today: It was never just about money. It was about who gets to own your time, your attention, your imagination, your future.
Artists weren’t the first to be squeezed, but we were the first to feel it. And the ways we’ve survived — scrappy self-solvency, shared infrastructure, mutual aid, stubborn artistic clarity — have always been the prototype for how people endure collapsing systems. Whether we call it Big Art/Little Debt or NonDē, the basics are the same. Artists have always made work with other people — in solidarity, in scarcity, in community — and the only thing that’s changed is our sharpened attention to who profits and whose voice is allowed to be heard. Mutual aid, shared infrastructure, self-determined risk, the refusal to be homogenized — these aren’t innovations; they’re the long-standing survival strategies of cultures that refuse to be captured.
This is what Big Art/Little Debt/Together points toward now: not rugged individualism but collective human sovereignty. Building the conditions for your artistic life — with others. Knowing exactly who you owe, and refusing to owe the wrong people. Refusing to be captured by a system that counts on your exhaustion.
Artists have always been the early warning system.
We feel the enclosure first.
We invent the exits first.
Big Art/Little Debt was never about being cautious.
It is about refusing to be owned.
